Class IITerminated · reported 2023-03-08

Limited Edition Winter Mint Chocolate Premier Protein 30g Protein High Protein Shake…

Niagara Bottling recalled this product and the FDA reported the enforcement action on 8 March 2023 as Class II. The recall was initiated by the firm. The recalled product did not meet the pre-kill step processing specifications and has the potential to be spoiled.

The record

Every field below is published by the FDA in the openFDA food enforcement database. Check the FDA notice before acting on any recall: this page is a reading of the public record, not a substitute for it.

Product
Limited Edition Winter Mint Chocolate Premier Protein 30g Protein High Protein Shake 11.5oz (340mL) UPC 00643843801498 packaged in plastic bottles in full wrap lithographpacked in a cardboard case, 12 packages per case
UPC
00643843801498
Reason for recall
The recalled product did not meet the pre-kill step processing specifications and has the potential to be spoiled.
Recalling firm
Niagara Bottling
Firm location
Diamond Bar, California, United States
Classification
Class II
Status
Terminated
Recall number
F-0382-2023
Quantity
1152 cases
Distribution
CA
Initiated
14 February 2023
Reported by FDA
8 March 2023
Terminated
3 April 2024
Firm notified by
E-Mail
Product codes
2235TEM6; Best By Dates 21OCT2023, 22OCT2023, 23OCT2023

Reading this record

Five things about this record are not in the record itself, and each one changes how it should be read.

  • Class II means the FDA judged a remote probability of serious harm, or a probability of temporary or medically reversible harm. The class is assigned by an agency health hazard evaluation under 21 CFR 7.41, not by the firm.
  • The firm started this recall itself. Most FDA food recalls are voluntary, and a recall is a food safety plan working rather than failing. The circumstances in which the agency asks for one instead are set out in 21 CFR 7.45.
  • This record is the only one the FDA opened for its recall event, so it covers a single product code.
  • The recall ran for 14 months, from 14 February 2023 to termination on 3 April 2024. Termination means the agency judged that all reasonable effort had been made, under 21 CFR 7.55, and it says nothing about whether product remained in circulation.
  • The distribution pattern names 1 state, and the FDA published the enforcement report 3 weeks after the firm began the recall.
  • Recalls of a snack or confectionery product run a median of 7 months, so this one was longer than usual for its category. Snacks and confectionery recall for allergens more than for anything else, because a chocolate or a coated snack passes through shared equipment carrying milk, soy and nuts, and the label is the only control between them and the consumer.

What this recall was for

Spoilage and mould

A spoilage recall means the food degraded before its date: mould growth, unintended fermentation, swelling or rancidity, usually traced to a seal, a formulation or a storage temperature.

A preventive controls plan covers spoilage under the clauses below. This is where the control belongs, not a finding against any firm named on this page: a recall record states a reason, and most of these recalls were initiated by the firm itself.

21 CFR 117.93
Warehousing and distribution: storage and transport under conditions that protect food against contamination and against deterioration of the food and its container.
21 CFR 117.80(b)(3)
Time and temperature: holding food at temperatures that do not allow microorganisms to grow, and for no longer than the process allows.

Filed under snacks and confectionery and prepared meals and sandwiches. A product can sit in more than one.

Other snacks and confectionery recalls for the same reason

These are the closest records in the corpus: the same kind of food, recalled for a hazard this record also names. Unlike the firm’s own records below, they come from different companies, which is what makes them a pattern rather than a history.

ReportedProductFirmReasonClass
2025-09-03Hostess Ding Dongs CHOCOLATE CAKE WITH CREAMY FILLING 2.55 oz twin pack UPC 8 88109 01002 7; 10-1.28 oz carton (12.7 oz) UPC 8 88109 11061 1; 16-1.28 oz carton (20.31 oz) Individual selling unit - UPC 8 88109 01182 6 16-count selling unit - UPC 8 88109 11092 5The J.M. Smucker CompanyMold. The firm noticed an increase in customer complaints. They conducted a root cause investigation and discovered that one of their coolers had malfunctioning.Class II
2025-06-11Sysco Classic chocolate pudding, 7lb #10 metal can, UPC 074865103817, 6 cans per case. Bay Valley Foods Thank You chocolate pudding, 7lb #10 metal can, UPC 041820062205 , 6 cans per case.Treehouse FoodsPost process damage to containers, potential for microbial growth, swollen and or exploding containersClass II
2025-04-23LEGALLY ADDICTIVE THE O.G. COOKIES MADE FROM CRACKERS+TOFFEE+CHOCOLATE+SEA SALT NET WT. 4.7OZ (133G) UPC 8 54766 00802 8 & 1.34OZ (38G) UPC 8 54766 02800 4Legally Addictive FoodsThe firm received complaints of a "rancid taste" from consumers.Class II
2024-10-02Montreal Fudge brand Chocolate Fudge with Nuts; 5.6ozAUTHENTIK FUDGEProduct may be contaminated with mold.Class II
2024-08-21Fox's u-bet Sugar-Free Chocolate Flavored Syrup, 18oz, UPC 070216246004, 12 retail units per wholesale caseSUBCO FOODS INCCustomer complaint for bloated bottles. Testing and examination of these lots has revealed they did not meet specifications, including elevated pH and water activity levels. This may be indicative of microbiological activity, and concurrent risk of food-borne illness.Class III
2023-10-04Cerebelly Smart Bar; Apple Kale flavor; 5 pk and 7 pk; ambient storageCEREBELLY INCSurface mold visible on productClass II
2023-10-04Cerebelly Smart Bar; Strawberry Beet flavor; 5 pk and 7 pk; ambient storageCEREBELLY INCSurface mold visible on productClass II
2023-10-04Cerebelly Smart Bar; Blueberry Banana flavor; 5 pk; ambient storageCEREBELLY INCSurface mold visible on productClass II

Other records from Niagara Bottling

The FDA opens one enforcement record per product code, so several of these are frequently one recall event.

ReportedProductFirmReasonClass
2023-02-08Limited Edition Winter Mint Chocolate Premier Protein 30g Protein High Protein Shake 11.5oz (340mL) UPC 00643843801498 packaged in plastic bottles in full wrap lithograph packed in a cardboard case, 12 packages per caseNiagara BottlingThe recalled product did not meet the pre-kill step processing specifications and has the potential to be spoiled.Class II

All 2023 recalls · All FDA food recall data

21 CFR 117.93 is the clause behind this recall, and it is one somebody has to produce evidence for at their next audit. Krolda maps supplier documents to the clause they satisfy in FSSC 22000, IFS Food and 21 CFR 117, and routes the corrective action when the evidence is missing.

Early access

Recall records come from the openFDA food enforcement API, published by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in the public domain. Krolda adds the hazard classification and the clause mapping; neither is an FDA determination. Always check the FDA notice before acting on a recall.